nightmare

Magic the Gathering MTG
-

Top 67 nightmare cards from Magic the Gathering.

Card Name
Rarity
Type
Expansion
#
7-Day
Regular
Foil
[119] 5b Rare Creature - Nightmare Horse Limited Edition Beta 119 -63 % 359.51
[380] 2wbg Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Cat Nightmare Beast Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 380 6 % 39.49 34.24
[378] 2bgu Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Nightmare Beast Elemental Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 378 1 % 21.42 24.6
[76] 3ub Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare Horror Crimson Vow Commander 76 13.35
[381] 1rwb Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Dinosaur Cat Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 381 1 % 8.64 9.16
[1645] bb Mythic Rare Creature — Nightmare Secret Lair Drop Series 1645 7.81
[1763] 3bb Mythic Rare creature — nightmare demon Secret Lair Drop Series 1763 7.2
[303] 2wbg Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Cat Nightmare Beast Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 303 12 % 6.26 11.61
[136] Rare enchantment creature — nightmare Promo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror 136 1 % 5.84 6.05
[67] 3bb Mythic Rare Creature — Nightmare Angel Promo Pack: Streets of New Capenna 67 10 % 5.78 3.7
[84] 1bb rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare Dominaria United 84 -3 % 4.99 4.96
[373] 6bb Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 373 5 % 3.39 4.33
[96] 3b Rare Creature — Nightmare Promo Pack: Core Set 2020 96 2 % 3.02 4.47
[299] 2bgu Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Nightmare Beast Elemental Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 299 3 % 2.55 5.28
[355] 1wbwb Rare Legendary Creature - Cat Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 355 2.49 4.81
[437] 3rrr mythic Creature — Nightmare Dragon Dominaria Remastered 437 8 % 2.28 6.4
[357] uuu Rare legendary enchantment creature — nightmare Duskmourn: House of Horror 357 1 % 1.74 2.42
[16] 1wbg Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare beast Commander 2020 16 1 % 1.6 0.94
[64] 8bbb Rare Creature - Nightmare Horror Torment 64 2 % 1.18 33.92
[43] Rare enchantment creature — nightmare Commander: Duskmourn: House of Horror 43 6 % 1.05
[12] 3bgu Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare Beast Commander 2020 12 2 % 1.03 0.65
[20] 1bgu Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare Hydra Commander 2020 20 -1 % 1.02 4.25
[209] 1rwb Mythic Rare Legendary Creature - Dinosaur Cat Nightmare Promo Pack: Ikoria 209 -4 % 0.92 1.03
[10] 2wbg Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Nightmare Insect Commander 2020 10 0.83 0.5
[208] ubb Rare Creature - Elemental Nightmare Promo Pack: Ikoria 208 0.75 1.03
[15] 3br Mythic Rare Legendary Creature — Cat Nightmare Commander 2020 15 0.75 0.33
[67] 4bb Rare Creature- Nightmare Horror Torment 67 29 % 0.69 29.33
[222] 1b Rare Creature — Nightmare Promo Pack: Wilds of Eldraine 222 -2 % 0.67 0.73
[213] 5ur Rare Legendary Creature — Phyrexian Nightmare Promo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One 213 0.67 0.72
[339] br Rare Creature - Nightmare Dinosaur Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 339 -2 % 0.64 1.16
[69] 1b Common Creature - Nightmare Horror Torment 69 -7 % 0.55 11.24
[58] 5uu Rare Creature - Nightmare Fish Beast Judgment 58 0.52 12
[44] 4bb rare Creature — Nightmare Commander 2020 44 14 % 0.5
[322] 1bb Rare Creature - Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 322 0.49 0.32
[38] 4uu Mythic Rare Creature - Nightmare Sphinx Guilds of Ravnica 38 0.49 2.55
[99] 3rr Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Orgg Judgment 99 0.49 8
[55] 3uu Rare Creature - Nightmare Fish Beast Judgment 55 0.47 2.2
[108] 6rr Rare Creature - Nightmare Beast Torment 108 0.46 4.63
[T12] Token Token Creature — Nightmare Theros Beyond Death T12 0.41
[43] 2bb Special Creature - Nightmare Horror Time Spiral "Timeshifted" 43 -14 % 0.4 1.32
[62] 4br Rare Creature - Nightmare Horse Ravnica Allegiance: Guild Kits 62 0.35
[58] 1u Uncommon enchantment creature — nightmare Duskmourn: House of Horror 58 -12 % 0.33 0.43
[222] 1bg Uncommon Creature — Nightmare Beast Commander 2021 222 -4 % 0.3
[56] 3u Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Crab Judgment 56 0.3 0.97
[541] b Common Creature — Nightmare Elf The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth 541 -10 % 0.29 0.26
[30] 3w rare Creature — Nightmare Commander 2020 30 8 % 0.29
[84] 1bb Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror Torment 84 4 % 0.28 3.15
[126] 2b Uncommon Legendary Creature — Nightmare Cat Commander Legends 126 9 % 0.25 0.26
[298] 2bg Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Beast Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 298 0.25 0.38
[288] 5b Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 288 0.25 0.34
[290] 3b Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 290 0.25 0.46
[302] 1wb Uncommon Creature - Cat Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 302 0.25 0.24
[104] 6bb uncommon Creature — Nightmare Horror Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 104 14 % 0.25 0.34
[90] 1bb uncommon Creature — Nightmare Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths 90 -27 % 0.25 0.2
[275] 2u uncommon Creature — Nightmare Merfolk Theros Beyond Death 275 0.25
[T6] Token Token Creature — Nightmare Horror Dominaria T6 0.25
[114] 1bb Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horse Core Set 2019 114 7 % 0.25 0.42
[108] 2b Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror Time Spiral 108 0.25 0.39
[60] 2u Uncommon Creature - Nightmare Turtle Beast Judgment 60 0.25 1.99
[57] 2u Common Creature - Nightmare Drake Judgment 57 0.25 0.44
[59] 1u Common Creature - Nightmare Salamander Beast Judgment 59 0.24 0.7
[62] 2b Common Creature - Nightmare Horror Torment 62 0.24 0.95
[85] 4b Common Creature - Nightmare Horror Torment 85 0.23 0.53
[118] 1ub Rare creature — nightmare bird Foundations 118 -30 % 0.2 0.08
[57] 1uu Uncommon enchantment creature — nightmare Duskmourn: House of Horror 57 36 % 0.2 0.21
[181] bg uncommon Creature — Nightmare Wombat Modern Horizons 3 181 50 % 0.2 0.15
[79] 3b uncommon Creature — Nightmare Wilds of Eldraine 79 -11 % 0.2 0.16

EchoMTG ©2025, ThoughtBomb Studios, LLC. Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions. Magic: the Gathering™ references are property of Wizards of the Coast. Lorcana references are property of Disney.

Clicking links to various merchants on this site and making a purchase can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network, TCGplayer.com, CardKingdom.com.